Difference between revisions of "Talk:Uvularia perfoliata"

(Bot: Adding {{TalkChanges|Original=[]|ChangedTo=Uvularia caroliniana (J. F. Gmelin) Wilbur|Location=Synonymy|Category=Synonymy|Reason=New synonym|FixedInFNA=yes|Comments=FNA26 148 Gandhi - 1. Uvularia puberula Mi)
 
m (Bot: Adding {{TalkChanges|Original=[]|ChangedTo=Uvularia pudica Fernald is an illegitate name that pertains here.|Location=Discussion|Category=Discussion|Reason=IIlegitimate name|FixedInFNA=yes|Comments=FNA26 148)
 
Line 1: Line 1:
 +
{{TalkChanges|Original=[]|ChangedTo=Uvularia pudica Fernald is an illegitate name that pertains here.|Location=Discussion|Category=Discussion|Reason=IIlegitimate name|FixedInFNA=yes|Comments=FNA26 148 Gandhi - 1. Uvularia puberula Michaux.msg Summary by Geoff: We'll never hear from Utech in answer to Kanchi's question, but other sources treat Uvularia caroliniana (J. F. Gmelin) Wilbur as a synonym of Uvularia perfoliata, so different from U. puberula; they also treat U. pudica Fernald as an illegitimate name pertaining to U. perfoliata. I suggest (1) deleting Uvularia pudica as a synonym of U. puberula (reason: not synonym), (2) adding U. caroliniana (J. F. Gmelin) Wilbur as a synonym of U. perfoliata (reason: new synonym), and (3) Adding the sentence "Uvularia pudica Fernald is an illegitate name that pertains here." to the end of the discussion of U. perfoliata (reason: illegitimate name). In all three cases, the source of the change can be listed as World Checklist of Selected Families.|Authority=World Checklist of Selected Families, 9 Nov 2010|Volume=26}}
 +
 
{{TalkChanges|Original=[]|ChangedTo=Uvularia caroliniana (J. F. Gmelin) Wilbur|Location=Synonymy|Category=Synonymy|Reason=New synonym|FixedInFNA=yes|Comments=FNA26 148 Gandhi - 1. Uvularia puberula Michaux.msg Summary by Geoff: We'll never hear from Utech in answer to Kanchi's question, but other sources treat Uvularia caroliniana (J. F. Gmelin) Wilbur as a synonym of Uvularia perfoliata, so different from U. puberula; they also treat U. pudica Fernald as an illegitimate name pertaining to U. perfoliata. I suggest (1) deleting Uvularia pudica as a synonym of U. puberula (reason: not synonym), (2) adding U. caroliniana (J. F. Gmelin) Wilbur as a synonym of U. perfoliata (reason: new synonym), and (3) Adding the sentence "Uvularia pudica Fernald is an illegitate name that pertains here." to the end of the discussion of U. perfoliata (reason: illegitimate name). In all three cases, the source of the change can be listed as World Checklist of Selected Families.|Authority=World Checklist of Selected Families, 9 Nov 2010|Volume=26}}
 
{{TalkChanges|Original=[]|ChangedTo=Uvularia caroliniana (J. F. Gmelin) Wilbur|Location=Synonymy|Category=Synonymy|Reason=New synonym|FixedInFNA=yes|Comments=FNA26 148 Gandhi - 1. Uvularia puberula Michaux.msg Summary by Geoff: We'll never hear from Utech in answer to Kanchi's question, but other sources treat Uvularia caroliniana (J. F. Gmelin) Wilbur as a synonym of Uvularia perfoliata, so different from U. puberula; they also treat U. pudica Fernald as an illegitimate name pertaining to U. perfoliata. I suggest (1) deleting Uvularia pudica as a synonym of U. puberula (reason: not synonym), (2) adding U. caroliniana (J. F. Gmelin) Wilbur as a synonym of U. perfoliata (reason: new synonym), and (3) Adding the sentence "Uvularia pudica Fernald is an illegitate name that pertains here." to the end of the discussion of U. perfoliata (reason: illegitimate name). In all three cases, the source of the change can be listed as World Checklist of Selected Families.|Authority=World Checklist of Selected Families, 9 Nov 2010|Volume=26}}

Latest revision as of 17:24, 28 May 2021

Change made
Original []
Changed to Uvularia pudica Fernald is an illegitate name that pertains here.
Location Discussion
Category Discussion
Reason IIlegitimate name
Volume 26
Authority World Checklist of Selected Families, 9 Nov 2010
Fixed in FNA SMW yes
Comments FNA26 148 Gandhi - 1. Uvularia puberula Michaux.msg Summary by Geoff: We'll never hear from Utech in answer to Kanchi's question, but other sources treat Uvularia caroliniana (J. F. Gmelin) Wilbur as a synonym of Uvularia perfoliata, so different from U. puberula; they also treat U. pudica Fernald as an illegitimate name pertaining to U. perfoliata. I suggest (1) deleting Uvularia pudica as a synonym of U. puberula (reason: not synonym), (2) adding U. caroliniana (J. F. Gmelin) Wilbur as a synonym of U. perfoliata (reason: new synonym), and (3) Adding the sentence "Uvularia pudica Fernald is an illegitate name that pertains here." to the end of the discussion of U. perfoliata (reason: illegitimate name). In all three cases, the source of the change can be listed as World Checklist of Selected Families.
Change made
Original []
Changed to Uvularia caroliniana (J. F. Gmelin) Wilbur
Location Synonymy
Category Synonymy
Reason New synonym
Volume 26
Authority World Checklist of Selected Families, 9 Nov 2010
Fixed in FNA SMW yes
Comments FNA26 148 Gandhi - 1. Uvularia puberula Michaux.msg Summary by Geoff: We'll never hear from Utech in answer to Kanchi's question, but other sources treat Uvularia caroliniana (J. F. Gmelin) Wilbur as a synonym of Uvularia perfoliata, so different from U. puberula; they also treat U. pudica Fernald as an illegitimate name pertaining to U. perfoliata. I suggest (1) deleting Uvularia pudica as a synonym of U. puberula (reason: not synonym), (2) adding U. caroliniana (J. F. Gmelin) Wilbur as a synonym of U. perfoliata (reason: new synonym), and (3) Adding the sentence "Uvularia pudica Fernald is an illegitate name that pertains here." to the end of the discussion of U. perfoliata (reason: illegitimate name). In all three cases, the source of the change can be listed as World Checklist of Selected Families.